The Alibi Archive

Three witnesses. One account contradicts the building's travel times.

Reasoning Tricky 4 min

Resets in --:--:--

Loading today’s puzzle…

How to play

Goal: Find the witness whose two statements cannot both be true.

  1. Read the three witnesses' statements. Each gives a time and a room.
  2. Compare each witness's two claims with the walking time between the rooms.
  3. Select either statement in the impossible pair. You have 5 attempts.
  4. Optional clues cost one attempt each.
  • A claim can be false only if the walk takes longer than the time between the two statements.
  • The other two witnesses are consistent, so you must check the timings rather than eliminate people.

About this puzzle

Three witnesses. One account contradicts the building's travel times.

Statements are evidence only if the times allow them. One witness claims two places too close together for the walk between them.

What you learn

You practise reading evidence closely, comparing times and spotting the one claim that cannot hold. Deduction you can use outside the puzzle.

  • Deduction
  • Evidence
  • Lateral thinking

A new puzzle appears at midnight UTC. Your streak is stored in this browser only — no account, no tracking, nothing uploaded.

Share this puzzle

Send the link to someone who would enjoy it.

Stored on this device only.